After pouring months, sometimes years, into writing and publishing your book, you will likely feel vulnerable and disheartened when a reader critiques your hard work. Receiving a negative review can feel like a punch in the gut.
However, negative reviews are a natural part of the publishing process, and how you respond can significantly impact your growth as a writer.
Instead of letting negative reviews affect you, why not embrace them with grace, learn from the criticism, and transform it into an opportunity for growth and improvement?
Why Negative Reviews Are Inevitable
First, it is important to understand that no matter how brilliant a book is, there will always be someone who doesn’t enjoy it. Readers have different tastes, preferences, and expectations, and your writing will not be universally liked or appreciated. Negative reviews are not necessarily a reflection of your ability as an author—they are just one person’s opinion.
Some common reasons why negative reviews happen include:
- Different Expectations: A reader may have picked up your book expecting something different based on the title, cover, or description. If they didn’t find what they expected, they may leave a poor review.
- Personal Preference: Writing is an art form, and it is subjective. What resonates with one person may not make sense to another.
- Issues with Writing Style: Some readers may find your writing style difficult to follow or unfamiliar, especially if they are used to more mainstream authors or particular genres.
- Pacing and Structure: Some books struggle with pacing or structure. If a book feels too slow in parts or has confusing plot twists, some readers might find that frustrating.
How to Handle Negative Reviews as a Self-Published Author
While receiving a negative review may sting, there are several effective ways to deal with it. Here is a guide to handling criticism constructively:
1. Pause Before Reacting
First, take a deep breath and resist the temptation to respond immediately. It is normal to feel hurt or defensive, but reacting impulsively can escalate the situation or make things worse. Step back from the review, allow yourself time to process the feedback, and come back to it with a clear mind.
- Why is this important? When you are emotionally charged, your response might be rash and unprofessional. Time and reflection give you the space to think about your response logically and calmly.
2. Separate Your Ego from Your Work
As an author, you can easily tie your personal identity to your book. However, it is crucial to separate your self-worth from your work. A negative review is not a judgement on who you are as a person. Instead, see it as feedback on your writing, which is something that can always be improved.
- Why this is important: You can consider the reviewer’s point of view objectively if your emotions are detached from your book.
3. Evaluate the Review for Constructive Criticism
Not all negative reviews are entirely unhelpful. A critical review can point out flaws or areas for improvement that you hadn’t noticed. Look for any specific feedback in the review that could help you improve your writing.
- What to look for:
Does the reviewer point out pacing issues or inconsistencies in the plot?
Are there issues with character development or dialogue?
Did the reviewer mention that both elements of the story didn’t connect with the writing style or themes?
4. Respond to the Review (If Necessary)
If you feel that a negative review is misleading or inaccurate, you may be tempted to engage with the reviewer. While it is generally a good idea to avoid engaging with hostile reviews, a calm and professional response can sometimes be appropriate.
- When to respond:
If the review includes factual inaccuracies (e.g., misinterpreting your plot or characters).
If the review appears to be a misunderstanding or a miscommunication.
If you want to politely thank the reviewer for their feedback.
- How to respond: Keep your tone polite, respectful, and professional. Avoid defending yourself or attacking the reviewer. Acknowledge their opinion, express appreciation for their time and feedback, and politely clarify any misunderstandings.
5. Don’t Take It Personally
Negative reviews are not personal attacks. They are the opinion of one person, and it is impossible to please everyone. Rather than focusing on the one or two negative reviews, take a broader perspective. If you have more positive reviews, focus on the constructive praise rather than the criticism.
6. Use Negative Reviews as a Learning Opportunity
Each review, whether positive or negative, can help you improve as an author. If you notice recurring themes in the negative feedback, take them into account for future projects.
- What to look for:
Are readers frequently mentioning similar issues (e.g., confusing plot, weak character development)?
Is there a pattern to the types of criticism you receive?
7. Don’t Let One Negative Review Derail Your Confidence
It is normal to feel disheartened after receiving a bad review, but don’t let it steal your motivation. Many successful authors have received negative feedback early in their careers. Think of negative reviews as a stepping stone towards improvement. Confidence is key to continuing your writing journey. Letting one review knock you off course can prevent you from creating your best work.
8. Focus on Your Long-Term Goals
A single review won’t make or break your career. As a self-published author, you have the power to continue improving, publishing, and marketing your books. Focus on your long-term goals, and remember that no single review defines your overall success. Negative reviews are just one moment in your journey as an author. Keep moving forward and focusing on your next project.
Common Questions Authors Ask Themselves When Facing Negative Reviews
Negative reviews often bring up a few questions. Here are some common questions authors might ask themselves, along with helpful answers:
1. “Is my book really that bad?”
- Answer: No, not necessarily. Remember, writing is subjective. One person’s critique may not represent the opinion of all readers. Focus on constructive criticism and see if there is something you can improve on in future works.
2. “Should I respond to the reviewer?”
- Answer: It depends. If the review is rude or hostile, it’s usually best not to engage. If it contains helpful feedback or misunderstandings, a polite, professional response can be beneficial.
3. “Should I change my book based on one negative review?”
- Answer: While it is important to take constructive criticism into account, don’t make drastic changes based on one person’s opinion. Look for patterns in feedback over time.
4. “What if the reviewer doesn’t understand my book?”
- Answer: Sometimes, misunderstandings happen. Rather than defending your book aggressively, try to understand where the reviewer is coming from. If there is a recurring misinterpretation, consider clarifying it in future editions or promotional material.
5. “Should I delete or ignore negative reviews?”
- Answer: It is generally a bad idea to delete or ignore negative reviews unless they contain offensive language or violate the platform’s guidelines. Reviews are important for building authenticity and credibility.
6. “How do I handle repeated negative reviews about the same issue?”
- Answer: If multiple reviews highlight the same issue, it may be worth revisiting your manuscript. Perhaps your pacing, character development, or writing style could be improved. Use these reviews as a learning tool.
7. “How can I prevent bad reviews in the future?”
- Answer: While you can’t eliminate bad reviews, you can reduce the chances of them occurring by ensuring high-quality editing, having beta readers review your manuscript, and being clear in your book description. Additionally, engaging with your readers and understanding their expectations can lead to more satisfied reviews.
Receiving negative reviews can be tough for authors, but good and bad reviews are a part of the journey. Negative reviews provide valuable feedback, and with the right approach, you can use them to improve your craft and become a better writer.
By taking time to reflect, focusing on constructive criticism, and remaining professional, you can handle negative reviews with grace and maturity. Ultimately, your ability to respond positively to criticism will contribute to your growth as an author and enhance your long-term success.
Embrace the feedback, learn from it, and continue writing! Have thoughts on handling negative reviews or tips for improving your writing? We would love to hear from you. Drop a comment below or reach out at www.chowilson.com; let’s start the conversation!
Thank you for sharing
You are welcome!